Spoleg | What is sports law?

Introduction

A. What is Sports Law?

Sports law is one of the newest branches of the legal system, determined by the fundamental principles and specific normative solutions belonging to constitutional, civil, criminal, and administrative law. Undoubtedly, from its inception to the present day, sport has been conducted based on certain predetermined rules. These specific predetermined rules provide for the realization of the core values on which sport is based and which are guaranteed by fundamental principles that ensure fair play and free competition.

In fact, the interaction resulting from the relationship between sports and law as two separate phenomena, each of which has developed independently, has provided the basis for the emergence of sports law as an independent branch of law. Sports law is a system of orderly regulations in the field of the sports system and sports activities. In other words, sports law is a system of legal concepts related to sports, sports organizations, sports activities, athletes, sports infrastructure, and legal proceedings related to civil law in sports and the conduct of sports activities.

In modern society, sport is a highly profitable activity that, in its normative content, is seriously included in all areas of law, including the law of obligations, commercial law, criminal law, and so on. Sports law brings together many areas of law in unique ways. Sports law and its legal regulation is a type of law that determines the developing field of legal relations in this area of sports.

Sport is a special legal field that defines specific decisions related to sports activities. Relationships in sports cannot be imagined without an appropriate legal framework that defines these relationships. Sports law and legislation in the narrow sense encompasses the entire system of sports activities, types of sports, relationships within sporting events, and sporting events. Sports law also specifies the requirements that arise during the occurrence of sporting events or by the participants.

This article uses credible scientific and legal sources, which are listed at the end of the article, to examine the concept, position, and various aspects of sports law. Also, numerous scientific articles from reputable legal journals such as the Marquette Sports Law Review, the Virginia Journal of Sports & Law, and other specialized publications have been used in the writing of this article.

Relying on these sources, we will continue to explain the position of sports law in the legal system, the necessity of legal regulation of sports, examine the various legal areas related to sports, and other aspects of this topic. It is hoped that this article can open a window towards a better understanding of sports law as an emerging and dynamic legal discipline.

B. The urgent need for legal regulation of sports

Since the beginning of the 21st century, the legal systems of some countries have recognized and accepted sports law through legislation in the field of sports and sports activities, in order to protect the values that sports provide and promote. The purpose of state intervention in sports relations is to provide legal standards that regulate the functioning of the sports system and the realization of sports activities, to enable the realization of the social functions of sports, which is possible only if there are specific laws and regulations for sports and sports activities that are supported by the state.

Law, defined as a set of rules that regulate human behavior and prescribe coercive sanctions, has been defined. Given this definition, we can conclude that since sport is one of the main human activities, it is the responsibility of the state and its legal system to provide specific norms to regulate this issue. In addition, the role of the state is to provide the possibility of realizing the social functions of sports by creating specific regulations and laws for sports and sports activities that are supported by the state.

If we compare sports law with criminal, civil, constitutional, and administrative law, we come to the conclusion that sports law is a young but very advanced and complex branch of law. Also, sports law is a special legal discipline in universities, institutes, and other educational and research centers in Western European and North American countries. The numerous experiences and results of scientific research of these institutions have special importance in the development of new sports regulations and legal protection mechanisms in sports and people involved in sports.

C. Defining Sports Law, sports and sporting standards

So far, there is no specific or generally accepted definition of sports law. One of the reasons for the lack of a unique and acceptable definition of sports law is the fact that this branch of the legal system has developed much later and has been separated as a separate legal branch. Another reason is its rapid development over the past decade, which has been demonstrated by a significant expansion of legislation on an increasing number of sports relations and other legal and social relations that occur in relation to sports.

The most common definition of sports law as an independent branch of the legal system is:

Sports law is "a set of orderly regulations in the field of the sports system and sports activities."

The definition of sports law science is also as follows: "Sports law science is a system of legal concepts of sports, sports organizations, sports activities, athletes, sports infrastructure, and legal proceedings related to civil law in sports and the conduct of sports activities."

Under conditions where sports acquire dimensions beyond national borders, the issue of its international nature and global definition becomes more attractive and important. In the field of international law, the European Charter for Sport from 1992 under the supervision of the Council of Europe provides the following definition of sport:

"Sport means all forms of physical activity which, through casual or organized participation, aim at expressing or improving physical fitness and mental well-being, forming social relationships or obtaining results in competition at all levels."

In this charter, sport is seen as a special social right for every individual and national governments are encouraged to take measures to secure this right. This concept is in line with the trends of modern society and has been accepted in the legislation of most countries.

Part One - Reasons for the Existence of Sports Law

A - The emergence of sports crimes and the need for criminal justice in sports

With the emergence of sports crimes and offenses that began to occur during or while performing sports activities or in connection with sports activities, the need for legal regulation of sports and sports activities became completely clear. The legal regulation of sports was necessary to determine penalties for violating legal norms, specified rules of the game, and sportsmanship. The development of these legal norms provided the basis for creating a legal mechanism for the administration of criminal justice in sports and related activities, as well as an opportunity for state intervention in sports relations.

From a historical point of view, the need for specific rules for sports competitions was discussed by Plato in his book "Laws," where he explicitly refers to the existence of specific norms for sports. The internationalization of sport made international law exert its influence on this particular area of prominent importance and dominance.

Some theorists have increasingly begun to question the traditional view that there is no body of law that can be described as an independent legal field called sports law. Among the critics of the traditional view are those who have taken a middle position. Some others believe that in the sports context, the use of the term "sports and the law" is more appropriate than "sports law."

With the occurrence of sports crimes such as corruption, bribery, money laundering, forgery, misuse, fixing, and organized sports crime that undermine the entire sports system in all countries of the world, the need for stronger legal intervention in sports to enforce criminal law and identify sports crimes and criminals becomes more evident.

B - The need to redefine areas of private law for sports

With the emergence of sports crimes and offenses that occur during or while performing sports activities or in connection with sports activities, the need to redefine some areas of private law, contract law, labor law, and trade law to adapt to the sports context becomes completely clear.

Today, there are a large number of contracts in the field of sports that cover a wide range of topics including media rights, sponsorship, equipment and apparel supply, construction and leasing of sports facilities, and so on. The regulation and execution of these contracts requires the application of specific principles of contract law in the sports context.

In the field of labor relations, sports also have unique characteristics that require the application of specific rules and regulations regarding athletes' employment contracts, coaches' contracts, and other stakeholders. In the same direction, sponsorship contracts, TV broadcasting contracts, and player transfers are also important aspects of trade law in sports that need to be adapted to the specific conditions of sports.

Therefore, without considering the principles and rules governing these areas of private law, it will not be possible to regulate the legal relations between the various sports stakeholders. For this reason, sports law should try to provide a comprehensive and coherent framework for safeguarding the rights of individuals and improving the legal order governing sports by redefining and adapting these legal areas to the specific realities of sports.

C - Sports autonomy and its basis in law

One of the important discussions in the field of sports law is the extent of sports autonomy from the ruling legal system. Proponents of sports autonomy believe that due to the specific nature of sports, this area should have independent governance and sports organizations and institutions should have extensive powers in setting and enforcing regulations.

On the other hand, another school of thought believes that sports, like other areas, should be under the supervision and control of the country's legal system and absolute independence cannot be granted to it.

What is certain is that the independence of sports must be based on the constitution, laws, and court decisions in national legal systems. Sports cannot be absolutely separate from the legal system of society, but at the same time, it is necessary to recognize the independence of sports within the framework of the law.

In fact, the independence of sports should be such that while observing legal principles and rules, it provides the ground for the growth and prosperity of sports. Therefore, enacting laws and regulations that, while recognizing the specific characteristics of the sports field, create a balance between the independence of sports organizations and legal supervision, is one of the important tasks of sports law.

Overall, sports law should strive to provide the ground for sustainable development and promotion of sports along with preserving the prevailing ethical and social values by using the capacities of the law to regulate the relations between sports and the government. At the same time, undue and harmful government interference in sports should be prevented so that sports can go through its evolutionary process.

Part Two - Debate on Sports Law as an Independent Legal Field

A - The traditional view: Sports law does not exist

The traditional view is that sports law is nothing more than a hodgepodge of different legal branches that are relevant in the sports context. According to this view, the term sports law is misleading because sport is a form of activity and entertainment that is governed by the entire legal system. Critics say that real sports law does not exist, but only the application of various legal fields in sports situations. They believe that the study of "sports law" essentially consists of traditional legal principles and concepts and does not include a separate set of specific principles. Therefore, from the point of view of traditionalists, sports law cannot be considered an independent legal set.

B - Middle position: Sports law is emerging as a field

Some experts challenge the traditional view and believe that considering the recent legal developments related to sports, a set of specific sports laws is gradually forming. For example, the enactment of national and federal laws such as the Sports Agent Regulation Act are signs of the growth of a specific legal set for sports. However, from the point of view of this group, this set of laws has not yet reached enough maturity to form a coherent subject area of law under the title of sports law. Therefore, at present, it is better to use the phrase "sports and law" instead of "sports law."

C - Pragmatic view: Sports law currently exists as a legal field

Contrary to the previous views, a group believes that sports law currently exists as a specific and independent legal field. Proponents of this theory point to the increasing volume of judicial decisions and specific laws related to the sports industry as a sign of the formation of a separate legal set.

From the point of view of pragmatists, referring to sports law merely as a combination of other legal fields ignores an important current reality, which is that now it is very rare for a subject area of law to be completely separate and independent from other legal fields. Theoretical overlaps exist not only in sports law, but also in other legal areas. Therefore, the existence of these overlaps is not a sufficient reason to deny the independent nature of sports law.

These individuals believe that the marginal view of sports and doubt about its dignity and importance have prevented the recognition of sports law as a scientific discipline. But considering the undeniable importance and role of sports in the contemporary world as a social and economic phenomenon, it cannot be ignored. The sports industry, like other commercial fields, requires legal rules and regulations to regulate affairs and guarantee the rights of stakeholders.

Several criteria have been proposed to prove the existence of a specific legal field, including:

Unique application of laws from other disciplines in a specific field

Existence of specific issues in a field that require specialized analysis

The necessity of addressing the topics of a field in numerous general and specific laws

Interaction between subject matter elements of a field

Conflicts between decisions of a field with other fields

Significant impact on business, economy, culture or society

Interventionist legislation to regulate relations in a field

Publication of legal casebooks in a specific field

Existence of specialized journals and publications in a field

Acceptance by law schools and attorneys

A significant portion of the above criteria are true for sports law, and therefore it can be claimed that sports law possesses the quality of an independent scientific and professional discipline. Of course, it should be noted that the demarcation between legal disciplines is always relative and to some extent arbitrary, and there is no formal process for approving a new field.

In fact, recognizing a specific legal field is a process through which jurists and researchers gradually realize the widespread application of law in a new social arena. Sports law can also consolidate its independent position by highlighting its specific legal components and functions in sports, while relying on the general principles and foundations of legal science.

This requires the participation of lawyers, professors, researchers, and the sports community itself in enriching the discourse of sports law. Recognizing the scientific and professional position of sports law is not merely an abstract debate, but a necessity for promoting this field of study and application and elevating its position in the country's educational and judicial system.

Part Three - Subject Areas of Law Involved with Sports

The existence or non-existence of sports law as an independent field does not negate the extensive connection of sports with various legal branches. Here are some of the most important legal areas related to sports:

A - Contract Law:

Although the traditional role of contract law in sports has diminished due to labor and antitrust laws, the principles of contract law still play a vital role in interpreting and executing collective bargaining agreements, the terms of individual contracts for players and coaches, sponsorship and marketing contracts, sports venue lease agreements, and other areas.

B - Labor Law:

Given the presence of labor unions in most sports disciplines, labor and antitrust laws significantly impact employment relationships in professional sports. Issues such as collective bargaining, terms of employment contracts, disputes related to strikes and league lockouts, and dispute resolution within the framework of labor law can be discussed.

C - Antitrust Law:

Since the 1970s, antitrust laws (especially the Sherman Act) have had a strong impact on the structure of relationships in professional sports and have led to a reduction in the power of team owners over players. The abolition of the reserve clause in baseball, the creation of the free agency system, the debate about the monopolistic nature of leagues, television broadcasting restrictions, and various aspects of the NCAA are examples of antitrust issues in sports.

D - Tort Law:

In general, the principles of tort law are applicable in the field of sports as in other areas, however, due to the specific nature of sports, the application of some tort liability rules is difficult, such as liability arising from the behavior of players during a match. The doctrine of assumption of risk, the standard of reasonable care, liability of manufacturers of defective equipment, medical malpractice, and liability to fans are among the topics in this area.

E - Constitutional and Statutory Law:

In addition to labor and antitrust regulations, today public laws play an important role in regulating sports relations. Laws related to the prohibition of gender discrimination (Title IX) and racial discrimination, prohibition of disability (ADA), doping control, taxation, and other topics, along with constitutional principles such as freedom of expression and privacy, are examples of the impact of public law on sports.

F - Other Areas:

Sports law is also related to many other areas of law, including intellectual property law, media law, international law, consumer and trade law, corporate law, tax law, and criminal law. Therefore, sports lawyers must have sufficient knowledge in various legal fields.

Part Four - Legal Practice and Sports Law

The professional activity of a lawyer in the field of sports is very diverse and fruitful. As mentioned, sports law covers almost all subject areas of law. Therefore, a sports lawyer must be the ultimate general practitioner who has mastery over a wide range of legal issues. A sports lawyer may act as a legal advisor to clubs and teams, a defender in legal disputes, or a combination of these two activities. In any case, a deep familiarity with the specifics of this emerging field is essential. Here are some of the services that sports lawyers may provide:

A - Athlete Representation:

Contrary to the common perception that considers player representation in contract negotiations to be the focus of sports lawyers' activities, this part constitutes a small fraction of the duties and opportunities of sports legal practice. However, the role of sports agents goes far beyond mere contract negotiation with the club and includes tax planning, investment, asset management, endorsement contracts, medical consultation, retirement planning and post-career planning, and legal advice.

B - Coach Representation:

Many professional and college coaches seek legal services in the areas of negotiating and executing employment contracts, endorsement contracts, dispute resolution with clubs, and disciplinary matters.

C - Club and League Counseling:

A sports lawyer, as a legal advisor to a club or league, in addition to negotiating contracts with players, participates in negotiating and drafting contracts for coaches and staff, sports venue lease agreements, construction and renovation contracts, marketing contracts, media contracts, overseeing legal disputes, interpreting and executing collective agreements, handling disciplinary complaints, and other issues.

D - Representation of Educational Institutions:

Lawyers active in this field deal with the conclusion and execution of employment contracts for coaches, administrators and other staff, handling disputes related to NCAA rule violations, gender discrimination, tort liability, construction and operation of sports facilities, protection of intellectual property rights, and risk management consulting.

E - Representation of Sports Facilities:

In this area, lawyers oversee lease agreements with teams, suppliers, contractors, and government agencies, and participate in disputes related to tort liability to spectators, disputes related to the Americans with Disabilities Act, and breach of contract.

F - Other Areas:

Representation of individual sports athletes, organizers of special events and tournaments, national and international federations and committees, media interests, and marketing organizations are other areas where sports lawyers play a role.

Part Five - Sources of Sports Law

Sports law has numerous sources that contain norms and regulations to regulate the main issues and activities of sports. In addition to legal sources that are the result of the activities of international organizations and law enforcement institutions in each country, there are numerous documents under the title of "general legal regulations," resolutions of international non-governmental organizations and transnational and national sports organizations that establish specific sports rules such as "competition rules" and "rules for organizing and holding sports competitions in various disciplines" and specify the guarantees of their violation.

The internal sources of sports law in each country can be divided into two categories: main and secondary sources. The main sources include: the constitution, sports laws, laws related to non-profit and public organizations. Secondary sources include: statutes and regulations of federations and sports organizations, competition and match rules, disciplinary rulebooks, and other internal documents of sports institutions.

Among the international sources of sports law are the following documents: the International Convention against Doping in Sport, the European Anti-Doping Convention, the European Sports Charter, the European Union's Declaration on the Specific Characteristics of Sport and its Social Function, and other strategic documents. These documents directly affect the activity of sports organizations and federations.

Part Six - Governance of Sport

The rules and regulations governing sports can be divided into four categories:

1- Rules of the Game:

Each sport has its own technical rules and specific laws, which are usually set by the international federations of that discipline. These rules form the core of the sport and are inherently unchallengeable during the competition.

2- Ethical Principles of Sport:

These principles, concerned with issues of sportsmanship and integrity, are known as the "spirit of the game." Although they are not formal and technical rules, they are invoked whenever the decisions of sports organizations are challenged in courts. They form a lex specialis with the unique characteristics of each discipline, although they are not necessarily universal.

3- International Sports Law:

It refers to the general legal principles that are automatically applicable in sports. Fundamental protections such as guaranteeing due process and the right of defense have penetrated the sports legal system in this way and create a rule of law in sports.

4- Global Sports Law:

It refers to the principles that emanate from the set of rules and regulations of international sports federations as a private contractual order. These rules have an independent and special identity.

Global sports law cannot be limited solely to the integration of general international principles, as these principles exist independently and are applicable. International sports law is also applied to sports and does not arise from the functioning of international sports federations. Rather, it is necessary for the principles of global sports law to be formed independently from within the sports system, although based on the foundations of general principles of international law.

Conclusion

This research shows that sports law is emerging and evolving as an independent and emerging legal branch. Due to its increasing social, economic, and cultural importance, sports cannot have sustainable development without relying on the legal system. On the other hand, the specific and unique realities of sports require special legal rules and institutions to regulate internal and external relations.

Therefore, sports law, by borrowing from the capacities of different branches of law and relying on general legal principles, as well as responding to the specific requirements of the sports arena, gradually establishes its scientific and practical identity. The different opinions about the disciplinary and thematic position of sports law indicate the difficulty and delicacy of this process. But in the end, sports law must be able to develop a philosophy, functions, and tools appropriate to sports while maintaining its connection with other legal orientations.

References:

Nafziger, James A. R. (1988). International Sports Law. Transnational Publishers.

Gardiner, Simon, et al. (1998). Sports Law. Routledge.

Davis, Timothy (2001). "What is Sports Law?" Marquette Sports Law Review, 11(2), 211-244.

Siekmann, Robert C. R., & Soek, Janwillem (Eds.). (2012). Lex Sportiva: What is Sports Law? Springer.

Beloff, Michael J., Kerr, Tim, & Demetriou, Marie (1999). Sports Law. Hart Publishing.

Thorpe, David, et al. (2013). Sports Law. Oxford University Press.

Healey, Deborah (2005). Sport and the Law. UNSW Press.

Parrish, Richard, & Miettinen, Samuli (2008). The Sporting Exception in European Union Law. TMC Asser Press.

Weistart, John C., & Lowell, Cym H. (1979). The Law of Sports. Bobbs-Merrill.

Weiler, Paul C., & Roberts, Gary R. (1998). Sports and the Law: Text, Cases, Problems. West Group.

Yasser, Ray, et al. (1997). Sports Law: Cases and Materials. Anderson Publishing.

Mitten, Matthew J., et al. (2013). Sports Law and Regulation: Cases, Materials, and Problems. Wolters Kluwer.

Cozzillio, Michael J., & Levinstein, Mark S. (1997). Sports Law: Cases and Materials. Carolina Academic Press.

Champion, Walter T., Jr. (1993). Sports Law in a Nutshell. West Group.

Greenberg, Martin J., & Gray, James T. (1998). Sports Law Practice. Lexis Law Publishing.

Wong, Glenn M. (1994). Essentials of Amateur Sports Law. Greenwood Publishing Group.

Thornton, Patrick K., et al. (2016). Sports Law. Jones & Bartlett Learning.

Fechner, Frank, & Arnhold, Johannes (2018). Handbook on International Sports Law. Edward Elgar Publishing.

Gardiner, Simon, et al. (2006). Sports Law. Cavendish Publishing.

Lewis, Adam, & Taylor, Jonathan (Eds.). (2003). Sport: Law and Practice. Butterworths Tolley.